Spring Water vs. Tap Water: A Comprehensive Comparison to Help You Make the Right Choice

Our Water

There are two approaches: natural spring water (in bottles) and filtered tap water (from a connected water dispenser). Both are safe, comply with European standards, and are suitable for different uses. This unbiased, fact-based page will help you make a choice, whether it leads you to one or the other.

What exactly are we talking about?

Definitions

  • Natural spring water

    Natural spring water

    Identified groundwater, collected at the spring, without chemical disinfection. Bottled at the source. Stable mineral composition. Regulated under Directive 2009/54/EC.

  • Natural mineral water

    Natural mineral water

    A subcategory of spring water, with a mineral composition whose beneficial properties have been recognized by experts. Évian, Vittel, and Spa are examples of this type.

  • Tap water

    Tap water

    Supplied through the public water system. In Luxembourg, it comes from groundwater and surface water and is treated by chlorination. Complies with EU Directive 2020/2184.

  • Filtered tap water

    Filtered tap water

    Municipal water that has undergone multi-stage filtration (activated carbon, microfiltration) at the point of use. Removes chlorine and particles without substantially altering the mineral content.

The 8 Criteria That Matter

Comparison

Criterion Spring water (bottled) Filtered tap water
Origin Underground spring identified A mix of groundwater and surface water
Treatment None (except for possible microfiltration) Chlorination + point-of-use filtration
Mineral Composition Stable, identifiable, guaranteed Varies by municipality
Taste Described by the source as “more natural” Neutral after filtration, chlorine-free
Logistics Regular deliveries of gas cylinders None (continuously connected)
Monthly cost (20 people) ~80–150 € ~70–120 €
Carbon Footprint Moderate (transport of gas cylinders) Low (no logistics)
Ideal for Premium image, home page, no plumbing required Campsites > 20 people, heavy use

Estimates based on the Luxembourg B2B market; adjust according to the actual configuration.

Good Use Cases for the Gas Cylinder

Choosing Spring Water

✓ You’re setting up a premium reception or lobby area
✓ You don’t have access to a water supply (isolated floor, mezzanine)
✓ You’re setting up a medical waiting room or office
✓ You’re setting up a temporary space (event, construction site, trade show)
✓ You want to get started quickly without a technical visit

Good Use Cases for the Network Fountain

Select the filtered network

✓ You’re equipping a site with more than 20 people
✓ You have an ambitious CSR initiative (reduced carbon footprint)
✓ You’re equipping an environment with high energy consumption (workshop, school, sports facility)
✓ You have access to a water supply (kitchen, water source)
✓ You’re looking for the most cost-effective monthly rate over the long term

What if we combined the two?

Mixed Option

Many of our customers use both solutions at the same time:

✓ Mains-connected water cooler in the break room/cafeteria (capacity, cost savings)
✓ Spring water cooler with a water bottle at the reception desk or in the client meeting room (image, taste)

This is often what our site selection study recommends for medium- or large-sized sites.

Three Common Myths to Dispel

Common Misconceptions

  • "Spring water is healthier"

    "Spring water is healthier"

    Not necessarily. The microbiological safety of both is guaranteed by standards. The difference lies in taste, traceability, and stable mineral composition—not in overall “health.”

  • "Tap water contains hormones"

    "Tap water contains hormones"

    Media fears are greatly exaggerated. EU regulations are strict. Filtration provides additional safety, not a “purification” of massive pollution.

  • "Filtered water no longer contains any minerals."

    "Filtered water no longer contains any minerals."

    False. Standard filtration removes chlorine and particles without substantially altering the mineral content. The result is water with a neutral taste, which is viewed positively.

Your Questions About Choosing

Frequently Asked Questions

  • Does spring water contain more minerals than filtered water?

    Not necessarily; it depends on the source. Some spring waters are low in minerals. Filtered tap water retains the mineral content of the local water supply. For daily consumption, low-mineral-content waters are generally recommended.

  • Which one is more environmentally friendly?

    A mains-connected water dispenser generally has a lower carbon footprint (no logistics involved with water bottles). But our water bottles can be reused for 70 cycles, which significantly narrows the gap. For a large facility: mains-connected. For a small space without plumbing: water bottles—no guilt—it’s better than buying packs at the supermarket.

  • Can we try it out before we decide?

    Yes. Upon request, we offer a trial period for certain configurations. You can also organize a taste test during a meeting (spring water vs. filtered water vs. tap water) to get a group opinion.

  • How is it different from bottled water from the supermarket?

    Quality (our water comes from an identified, monitored source), cost (€0.50 to €1 per liter at the supermarket vs. less than €0.15 per jug), and plastic footprint (single-use vs. jugs that can be reused 70 times).

We'll help you choose—without any bias.

Ready to switch to Aquavital?

Our role: to help you find the solution that best fits your actual needs.